1031taxreform.com

A Section 1031 like-kind exchange reform resource

  • Economic Studies
    • EY Macroeconomic Study Overview
      • Ernst & Young Macroeconomic Study Press Releases
      • Ernst & Young Macroeconomic Study Speaker Biographies
      • Ernst & Young Macroeconomic Study Sponsors
    • Ling and Petrova Microeconomic Study Overview
      • FEA Ling and Petrova Press Release
      • Ling and Petrova Microeconomic Study Authors
    • NAR LKE Survey 2015
    • Contact Us: Section 1031 Economic Studies
  • Issues
    • Current Repeal Proposals
      • House of Representatives
      • Senate
      • White House – Treasury
      • Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT)
    • Like-Kind Exchanges Needed with Expensing
    • Legislative History
  • Resources
    • FEA Library
    • Resources for Supporters
    • Testimonials
    • Supportive Organizations
    • FAQs
  • News
    • §1031 In The Press
    • FEA §1031 Activity
    • Partner §1031 Activity
    • Submit a News Article
    • Press Room
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Press Room
  • Take Action
  • 1031.org

Ernst & Young Macroeconomic Study Overview

  • Overview
  • Press Releases
  • Speaker Biographies
  • Testimonials
  • Section 1031 History
  • Sponsors
  • Contact

EY logo

Download the Study

Click to download the study, “Economic Impact of Repealing Like-Kind Exchange Rules.”

DOWNLOAD REPORT

Released March 2015. Revised November 2015

Important Links

  • E & Y Macroeconomic Study Overview
  • Press Releases
  • Speaker Biographies
  • Testimonials
  • Section 1031 History
  • Sponsors
  • Contact

About the Study

This Ernst & Young analysis examines the macroeconomic impact of recent proposals to repeal the IRC Section 1031 like-kind exchange rules. These rules are used extensively in the real estate, transportation, equipment/vehicle rental and leasing, and construction industries.

Resource Documents (PDF)

  • EY Section 1031 Economic Study
  • Coalition Synopsis of the Section 1031 Economic Study
  • Revised Study Press Release PDF
  • Coalition Press Release PDF
  • EY Like-Kind Exchange Infographic
  • Like-Kind Exchange Fact Sheet
  • FEA History of Section 1031 PDF
  • Section 1031 Testimonials PDF
Ernst & Young Section 1031 Macroeconomic Study

Economic Impact of Repealing Like-Kind Exchange Rules

Highlights:

The study finds that repeal of IRC Section 1031:

  • results in less federal revenue
  • shrinks the U.S. economy, up to $13.1 billion annually
  • discourages investment
  • negatively impacts the overall economy, with an unfair concentration in certain industries
  • unfairly burdens certain businesses and taxpayers
  • is at cross-purposes with the goals of tax reform.

Findings:

The analysis finds that repeal of the like-kind exchange rules increases the cost of capital in the economy, even when combined with lower tax rates. The higher cost of capital is found to discourage business investment which adversely affects the overall economy.

Repealing like-kind exchange rules would subject businesses that rely on these rules to a higher tax burden on their transactions, resulting in longer holding periods, greater reliance on debt financing, and less-productive deployment of capital in the economy. Moreover, many affected businesses are in pass-through form, which would not receive a benefit if the revenue from repeal of like-kind exchange rules is used to finance a lower corporate income tax rate.

Implications:

The net impact suggests that this policy change is at cross-purposes with some of the objectives of tax reform. While repealing like-kind exchange rules could help fund a reduced corporate income tax rate, its repeal increases the tax cost of investing by more than a corresponding revenue neutral reduction in the corporate tax rate.

Repeal of Like-Kind Exchange Rules Would Cause:

Higher Cost of Capital

Even when combined with combined with lower taxes, the higher cost of capital negatively affects the economy across different uses of the associated revenue.

Increased Holding Periods

Survey respondents of both personal property and real estate like-kind exchange activity expect that asset holding periods would increase by more than 20% under repeal.

Increased Reliance on Debt Financing

Repeal would increase the cost of equity financing, as businesses would pay tax upon sale. This makes debt financing relatively less expensive. Consequently, businesses may increase their leverage by borrowing funds.

Reduction of the Velocity of Investment

Longer holding periods reduce the velocity of investment, meaning capital is redeployed in the economy more slowly.

Impact on GDP, Investment and Labor:

When the revenues are used to finance a revenue neutral reduction in the corporate income tax rate, this analysis finds that the combined impact would result in a smaller economy, with less investment and lower labor incomes for workers.

  • GDP is estimated to fall by $8.1 billion each year (0.04% decline in 2013 dollars) in the long-run.
  • Investment is estimated to fall by $7.0 billion (0.18% decline in 2013 dollars) in the long-run.
  • Labor income is estimated to fall by $1.4 billion (0.11% decline in 2013 dollars) in the long-run.
Important Comparisons
Estimated tax revenue to Treasury over 10 years (repeal score for years 2014-2023 by Joint Committee on Taxation) $40.9 billion
Estimated reduction of overall U.S. GDP over 10 years (EY Study) ($61 – $131 billion)

This analysis finds that pairing the repeal of this provision with a revenue neutral reduction in the corporate income tax rate would adversely affect the economy in the long-run.

Long-run effect of repeal on GDP each year under revenue-neutral reduction in the corporate income tax rate and alternative policy scenarios

chart1

Study Sponsors

This Ernst & Young study was sponsored by The Section 1031 Like-Kind Exchange Coalition.

Federation of Exchange Accommodators
Lynn Harkin, CAE, Executive Director
Federation of Exchange Accommodators
1255 SW Prairie Trail Parkway
Ankeny, IA 50023
Email: director@1031.org
Phone: 515-244-6515
Fax: 515-334-1174
www.1031.org

Williams & Jensen
701 8th Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20001
Phone: 202-659-8201
Fax: 202-659-5249
www.williamsandjensen.com

Copyright © 2021